Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Garcinia Cambogia: This again?

I apparently don't watch enough TV or visit enough supplement shops (which is probably a good thing).  The other day I was driving home and saw an advertisement for this particular weight loss supplement, garcinia combogia, advertised for 25% off.  Since it was something recommended by Dr. Oz I was already suspicious, and an Internet search confirmed my suspicions.  Once I started to write a blog about it, however, I realized that 1) this "new/amazing" supplement has actually been promoted for more than 15 years and 2) other writer's and bloggers have beaten me to pointing out the lack of evidence. 

So with that, I give you this excellent article written by Julia Belluz and Stephen J. Hoffman over at Slate: Can you trust Dr. Oz?  (Hint, the answer is no).

Let me highlight here that the 1998 study that indicated that the garcinia extract was no better than a placebo for weight loss was a randomized-controlled trial, also known as the gold-standard for a clinical trial.    So if you go on Amazon.com or your other favorite supplement retailer you get to spend about $20-$30 a month for something that works no better than a placebo.  That should be a deterrent to any good skeptic.

I also want to put in a reminder to watch out for the logical fallacy known as the Appeal to Ancient Wisdom.  Just because something is billed as having been "used for hundreds of years" in "insert country that seems exotic to those who live in Western societies here" does not mean that it has any practical medical application today.

Take home message--if you use garcinia extract to lose weight you are spending money that you could put toward your healthy food budget.

Now excuse me, I will go stalk Dr. Oz's website for more blog material.  I might be awhile.

14 comments:

  1. FYI, one of the useful tools that can make it even easier to identify bogus claims and find other related information is a tool called "RbutR" (Root is regarding rebuttals).

    Tracking down a link to Oz's site regarding that compound pops up a notice that there is a rebuttal to the claim and links to the following page (which has largely the same information as the slate article you link to above):

    http://www.denverpost.com/opinion/ci_22305784/dr-oz-miracle-diet-is-malarkey

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  4. If you should be concerned about your weight gain issues and searching for the perfect approach to melt excess fat within your body,Then this Garcinia Cambogia is helpful product for you all.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The internet is bogged down with bogus blogs with no real message but the post was fantastic and well worth the read.Thank you for sharing this with me.
    amino acid

    ReplyDelete
  6. Green energy drinks are chock-full of the immune boosters necessary to keep your body primed to fight invading viruses.
    Green drink

    ReplyDelete
  7. Great post. Thank you very very much.This article is efficient. Thank you for sharing it with us.Reducing your appetite, blocking fat from being made, and improving serotonin levels in your body are just a couple of exciting breakthroughs learned about Garcinia Cambogia! The most exciting part about Garcinia Cambogia is it can work on its own! No more time wasted searching for expensive weight loss products and no more hours wasted at the gym!Garcinia Cambogia Extract is finally here!

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hallo - Es ist gut, wie interessante Inhalte zu lesen. Ich stimme mit vielem, was hier geschrieben steht, und ich werde wiederkommen.
    Nochmals vielen Dank für die Buchung so große Lektüre !! Um weitere relevante Informationen finden Sie hier
    Pure Cambogia Ultra
    Pure Cambogia Ultra kaufen

    ReplyDelete
  9. Please continue to write more because it’s unusual that someone has something interesting to say about this.
    Will be waiting for more! I have some relevant information you can review below.
    Buy Garcinia Total Diet
    Garcinia Total Diet Reviews

    ReplyDelete
  10. I enjoyed reading your articles. This was a great read for me. I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.
    I have some relevant information you can review below
    pure cambogia ultra
    pure life cleanse

    ReplyDelete
  11. Danke für diesen informativen Artikel, hat mir sehr gefallen! Vielleicht mögt ihr ja mal auf meiner Seite schauen – ich interessiere mich sehr fürs Thema Beauty und habe einen Testbericht über ein neues Abnehm-Produkt namens Premium Cambogia Ultra & Pure Detox verfasst!
    Premium Cambogia Ultra Inhaltsstoffe
    Premium Cambogia Ultra test

    ReplyDelete
  12. weight lose faster! Lose Weight Without Changing Your Diet! Premium Garcinia Cambogia 30% Instant Online DISCOUNT Today.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I have tried so many diets system that I can't even remember them all. I just following pro fitness coach guidelines which is simple and it works. Get free coach online ProFitnessCoach4u

    ReplyDelete
  14. Slim-Fizz is a distinct appetite suppressant the ground breaking fibre Glucomannan, which is a natural dissolvable fibre derived from high quality fresh Konjac.

    ReplyDelete